The old reductio ad absurdum: stating an opponent's argument in a weak
manner in order to build an easily destroyed strawman.
I suppose we've all been guilty of that at one time or another. For some,
sadly, it is a habit. Hopefully most of us just sometimes get carried away with
our enthusiasm.
I did a Google search of the phrase "anything can be made to sound
ridiculous" and found a rich and colorful selection of appeals to that thought
variously stated:
Anything can be made to sound ridiculous if said with a
certain tone....
Anything can be made to sound ridiculous if it is
sufficiently distorted....
Anything can be made to sound ridiculous if you're willing
to lie about it....
Anything can be made to sound ridiculous. A Rembrandt
etching could, after all, be described as a piece of torn paper into which a
scratched piece of metal has been pressed.
Almost anything can be made to sound ridiculous by
dumbing it down in such a
manner.
manner.
By the way, notice how anything can be made to
sound ridiculous if you phrase it the right way?
Anything can be made to sound ridiculous by
gutting them of their meaning and
value....
value....
Anything can be made to sound ridiculous if
you try.
Almost anything can be made to sound
ridiculous when it is mocked by
exaggerating it to the extreme.
exaggerating it to the extreme.
Anything can be made to
sound ridiculous and petty if the debaters are skilled
enough at rhetoric.
enough at rhetoric.
But anything
can be made to sound ridiculous if it is taken out of context and
subjected to the reductionist approach.
subjected to the reductionist approach.
Part of my
point is that anything can be made to sound ridiculous or
terrible if you word it the right way, and focus on some detail, taken out of
context.
Using your sarcasm, anything can be made to sound
ridiculous.
Anything can be made to sound ridiculous or
conspiratorial if you try hard enough.
Well yeah, I mean if you're gonna cherrypick quotes like that, then
anything can be made to sound
ridiculous.
Anything can be made to sound ridiculous. It's
in the eye of the beholder.
I think we bloggers are prone to doing this, especially when we are riding
our hobby horses. Alas, we are only human.
Hmmm. Someone close to me does this- just a tone or a raised eyebrow can deflate me during a conversation.
ReplyDeleteOh well, these things can make us stronger!
It used to bother me, but no more. As you suggest, "these things can make us stronger."
ReplyDelete