It was Friedrich Nietzsche who suggested
He who fights with monsters should look to it that he himself does
not become a monster.
I was once a monster myself and am determined not to be one again.
Recently I reaffirmed my faith in God. It lay dormant for a long, long
time. During that time I aired the bitterness I had accumulated over the years
since I kissed faith good-bye.
Well, that's the thing. The bitterness. It grieves me when I look back over
the years and think of the hassles I gave "people of faith" (God, how I used to
hate that phrase and now I am such myself) during my self-imposed exile. All
because I was bitter. I felt God had let me down.
I meant well. I thought I had laid down a load and was trying to help
others unburden themselves. Only they didn't feel a burden. Oops.I thought I was
fighting monsters but instead had become one myself.
Something I've noticed: It seems to me that the most difficult nonbeliever
there is to deal with is the one who used to be a fundamentalist/evangelical
Christian. They can morph into monsters, mean-spirited and overbearing. I
did.
Besides the sheer discourteousness of a gratuitous attack on a person's
religious beliefs, there is the fact that such an approach is almost totally
useless. Such attacks only cause the faithful to dig in deeper and promotes
return hostility.
Even though I have returned to faith in God I still have an intense dislike
for fundamentalism. I honestly believe it is the bad face of
religion. Fundamentalists can be monsters with their faith. A worthy goal, it
seems to me, would be to help these folks along to a less monstrous approach to
spirituality. I doubt that can be done by viciously attacking views they hold
deeply and sincerely.
Yes, religion does have an ugly side. But so too does nonbelief. Faith
can transform itself into an ugly and abusive cocksureness, but so can reason.
That is the monstrous aspect of the matter. From either end I think it is
necessary to fight the monster without becoming one.
I like to think the monsters are much in the minority. Love and reason
should prevail. Arrogance is totally out of place here.
"It seems to me that the most difficult nonbeliever there is to deal with is the one who used to be a fundamentalist/evangelical Christian. They can morph into monsters, mean-spirited and overbearing."
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely. I've met several atheist ex-fundamentalists who failed to jettison the arrogance and confrontational spirit of their old fundamentalism. VERY unpleasant people.
After leaving Catholicism, I was pretty hot-headed about religion as a young nonbeliever. I'm relieved that I outgrew that arrogance, since it wasn't constructive or respectful.
Hi Ahab. I didn't you are a former Catholic. But I think you nailed it exactly. Some ex-fundamentalists retain their fundamentalist arrogance and confrontationalism. It just isn't helpful, except perhaps as a pressure-relief valve for them.
DeleteExcellent Doug. We all have to learn these things. Bob Dylan wrote (as he was exiting his protest stage):
ReplyDelete"Ah but I was so much older then, I'm younger than that now."
Never was a Dylan fan but that is a funny line.
Delete